Ouran High School Host Club: Better in Black and White

Ouran High School Host Club is one of those must watch Anime that truly stands above so many others. It is possibly one of the, if not the, best harem anime ever made. I however, have found something so much better, the Ouran High School Host Club Manga.

The first thing I noticed about the manga was that there were subtle story differences between it and the anime. Most of this had to do with the individual story order and when events occurred. At one point I was pretty sure I had reached the end of where the anime had received its inspiration, but I was wrong, I still had to read the introduction of Kasanoda which incidentally I enjoyed more in the Manga.

There were also differences within the stories, the most prominent being the Alice in wonderland chapter. I’m pointing this out because I really appreciate the fact that the anime and manga are different and yet still true to each other. This was Something I had yet to see Between an adaption and it’s source material where neither suffered. So far I’ve found that there is only new material in the anime, but that everything the manga has to offer had been used up by the anime or clearly wasn’t worth adapting, or the only difference comes from the story divergence that is usually due to an incomplete manga. That isn’t the case here. (Kind of, the manga wasn’t complete when the anime was made) I’m glad because otherwise it feels like going back and reading the manga is pointless. So while it’s a shame not all the early chapters were adapted, I prefer it this way.

The second thing I noticed was the art. It was anything but a static black and white version of what eventually was adapted into a vibrant action filled anime.

There is an action filled fluidness to Bisco Hitori’s art that gives such a vibrant life to the characters. They always seemed to be moving and when they weren’t it felt entirely intentional.

Screenshot_2018-02-08-21-48-06

The best part is that as the manga continued the art only got better. The characters became better drawn and more distinct, (when not in the ever cute chibi form), the action more pronounced, the emotions became more strongly conveyed and the comedic elements better placed.

This page in particular, near the end, is one of my favorites (I’m using a scantalation for picture ease, I read the series in paperback.)

Screenshot_2018-02-08-21-52-19

Thirdly, I noticed some amazing character development. Ouran high school host club is easily best known for the stereotypes that make up each character. “The princely type, the cool type, the mischievous type, the boy Lolita type, and the strong silent type.” Then of course there is Haruhi who is indifferent to everything and is literally dragged along through every activity.

While you get some character development and growth through the anime and in fact it is one of the anime’s strong points, taking stereotypes and turning them into characters, the anime really only brushes the surface.

Everyone in the manga has grown by the end, even most of the side characters have changed in some way or another. While most of the growth seems to be focused on Haruhi, Tamaki and the twins, even Kyoya, Honey and Mori have changed by the end. It really is amazing how subtly this is done to Honey and Mori. They honestly felt like the most static characters in the series, but by the end I had to concede that my view of them and how they were had changed a little. This is true amazing character development, the kind you don’t notice till the end.

These three things make the Ouran Manga a must read for any fan of the anime. And if you haven’t seen the anime you really must!

Beyond these though is the over arching story. Ouran first and foremost is a comedy, but as the series goes on more serious, romantic and dramatic moments come about. I have garnered that some feel apprehensive about reading the manga due to its more serious plot, but have no fear, Bisco Hitori doesn’t have a single mean bone in her body and she will see the characters through.

The comedy rarely wavers and in fact is only enhanced and bettered by the serious and dramatic moments. I laughed more in the 2nd half then I did in the first half (I cried more too, but only a couple times)(sob, sob, oh when March finally came!). In fact I think comedy wise the manga itself stands far above the anime.

Seeing the stories of these characters come to a dramatic head and then concluded was one of the most satisfying reading experiences I have had. It wraps everything up perfectly and unlike the anime I didn’t feel the same withdrawal upon completion. I was happy!

While Ouran High School Host Club may not be my favorite anime (though it is near the top), I truly believe it will remain my favorite manga for a long time to come.

 

 

 

7 thoughts on “Ouran High School Host Club: Better in Black and White

  1. That’s really interesting, I’ll have to check it out once I’ve finished the show, I got quite a way in and just forgot about it.

    Luckily for me the last time I went to the library they had all of OHSHC which means I can read the whole thing in physical form very easily!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. You forgot about it ­čś▒ *laughs*

    It’s much better to read it in physical form, things are just overall cleaner and better translated. I used my library too, but i will be buying the series as soon as I can.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Yeah but it happens, it’s a great show but it doesn’t give me an urgency for watching it so I don’t have any issues saving it for later.

      Also manga costs way too much for me to think it’s worth it, if I have a strong attachment (like Berserk) I might buy the first couple of volumes but that’s about it. Scans are good enough for me most of the time. I like supporting the industry but it’s difficult justifying it with the expensive cost when it takes so little time to read!

      Also I don’t think you replied to my comment, I think you just wrote it out as a normal comment on it’s own. So sorry if you were just saying random things to the world!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Oh, did it not come back as a reply? Sorry, I must have pushed the wrong button when i went to write my reply.

        Normally I’m pretty tight with my money, but I saw I can get them pretty cheap through Wal-Mart last time I checked. I just need to save up a bit. I loved it so much, I just want to be able to sit down in my room and read it whenever I want. No worries about internet connection. Scan accessibility, because who knows if they’ll take it down (I was surprised I even found a scan for picture proposes.) Plus, it’s easier to flip to certain scenes, and I can see myself reading certain chapters out of order more then others.

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Yeah I can understand wanting to do that, it sounds like a really good thing actually.

          Just recently I got into Bakuman (like today) and I now think I understand the emotions of wanting to buy something to just have!

          Liked by 1 person

  3. I’m excited to learn that you enjoyed the manga even more than the anime. That’s always pleasant to experience.

    Soooo what’s the first app in your phone screenshots? The icon resembles a burger, which has me very interested.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh, haha! I couldn’t remember the name for a few seconds, but I just got a notification for it and that reminded me. It’s called Cooking craze. It’s a cooking game with levels like candy crush. Very fun. I searched for a long time for a good mobile cooking game and this is it.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s